It is well known that the county policy regarding cell phones is quite strict this year. Phone usage has been banned in all Rutherford County schools, and students who violate these rules face consequences. There also seems to be an outcry against the “stupid” and “unfair” rule.
School phone bans are in effect in 20 states and partially enforced in 16 states.
Reasons why it exists:
Reduction of Distractions: To stop the decrease of conducive learning and improve engagement with the subject and fellow classmates in a focused environment.
Mental Health: Studies show that schools are concerned about increased anxiety and depression due to social media. Limited access could help reduce pressure and FOMO, as stated by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt regarding the correlation of increased social media use; he advocates phone bans as a possible remedy.
Engagement: Students who aren’t glued to their phones have a higher rate of developing better communication skills and encouraging immersion through participation in collaborative learning and discussions.
Like/Dislike for it:
Some students’ academic performance improves as they believe it helps them concentrate better during school.
Many students feel that the ban has enhanced their social skills and engagement, making learning more enjoyable. Students value increased productivity with reduced phone usage. The cons of the phone ban have led to new distractions that affect learning. Students may depend on phones for communication with family and friends as their socialization decreases.
Many students fear that safety and security will be harder to access without direct contact with emergency contacts.
“It’s fair for the teachers as students aren’t paying attention, but unfair to students as they have no emergency access,” says junior Jimena Blasi.
“It’s both fair and unfair,” stated junior Mariana Volderrama.
The matter of phone bans is subjective, as some may benefit while others miss the convenience and communicative access that phones provide. It is an ongoing debate between supporters of the ban and those who oppose it. The phone ban isn’t a catastrophic rule but does alter students’ and teachers’ experiences in school.
